Washing A Book’s Mouth Out with Soap; There’s an App for That

profanityMy, my, sometimes nothing sums up a situation, emotion, or feeling, like a good old fashioned f-word. I’m no stranger to throwing in some profanity into blog posts and stories; these wicked little words are part of our language and culture and they serve a purpose. 

It appears that an app called Clean Reader allows readers to replace/hide all profanity in books. And they’re not calling it what it is: censorship and copyright infringement. Text is changed/edited without the author’s consent. 

I first heard about this over at Chuck Wendig’s site, who wrote a fantastic commentary about this growing issue and I urge you to check it out. I also encourage you to read an email that author Joanne Harris received from Clean Reader and her stellar response

Regardless of how you feel about profanity, is it right for anyone to alter someone’s book? Fuck no.

UPDATE: I should note that Clean Reader only allows readers to change words/text after they’ve purchased the book and are reading it on their own private devices. Sure, anyone can do anything to a book after it’s purchased, and according to Clean Readers, they’ve consulted with a gaggle of attorneys to ensure copyrights are not infringed upon, but something about this still irks me. There’s also a rumor floating around that the developers of Clean Reader are reselling “scrubbed up” versions of books . . . it’s worth investigating.

Here’s another take on the issue I recommend checking out.

2 thoughts on “Washing A Book’s Mouth Out with Soap; There’s an App for That

  1. Patricia Stoltey

    Amen! Just read Chuck’s full blog post and couldn’t even leave a comment because his circuits were busy!

    I know a lot of fictional characters (such as my Fat Ass Sammy Grick) who would go from vicious, angry thug to milquetoast wimp without his f-words. Clean Reader would clearly alter my character as well as the tension level in the book. And then would that reader go review my sanitized novel? Scary thought.

    Thanks for passing on the link, April.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *